Blue Anorak

Last modified on Monday, 23 April 2007 at 21:14:14

Match report

Southend United 3-2 Shrewsbury Town

From: Matthew Walker
Subject: Southend 3 Shrewsbury 2
Date: Mon, 18 Oct 1999 13:33:29 +0100

Just a few thoughts . . .

  1. Bob Sills asked me to convey to the list the fact that he thought that the ref was one of the best he'd seen at the Hall this season (IHHO). I am largely in agreement with that, although he wasn't helped by some hapless assitants (at least one offside decision in the second half defied belief) and missed one blatant hand-ball by them just outside the area. Apart from that, though, I thought he had a good game.
  2. Tolson and Carruthers looks like the basis of a sound striking partnership, although I think that they need to be accompanied by (and apologies for sounding as if I am chanting the same boring and hopeless mantra) a midfield terrier of the likes of Lee Hodges - someone who is going to chase and harry a bit harder than the current midfield. I still like the look of Tinkler, but his best role is definitely that of a Libero— a sort of Matthias Sämmer, that sits in front of the defence, sweeping up attacks and protecting the back four, whilst at the same time starting attacks by moving the ball from defence to midfield.

    My ideal formation would be to drop Booty, move Beard to right back, switch to a 4-4-2, and find an attacking midfielder of the likes of Lee Hodges. At the moment, I'd be inclined to give Morley a go in that attacking role (if, as has been suggested, his performances in the reserves have been as good as many suggest), but that's only in the absence of more obvious options. Can those who watch the reserves on a regular basis suggest anyone of the youngsters (Kerrigan?) who might fit into that attacking terrier rôle? Earlier on in the season, I would have suggested Cross for right-back and Beard in the midfield, but the midfield (at the moment) does not seem to bring the best out of Beard - he seems much happier marauding up and down the right hand touch-line.

  3. The quality of crossing was again poor. The best cross of the afternoon was, in fact, one that Scotty did - although I'm not sure that it was entirely intentional. Initially it was such a 9-iron sort of cross that most in the South Upper groaned, until the nice bit of backspin on the ball made it hover and then drop very invitingly at the far post - it caused a great deal of concern in the Shrewsbury box, and we were unlucky not to score as a result of the confusion. However, I don't think that any of our goals came around from high quality crossing by us; it was more like really poor defending from Shrewsbury.
  4. Apart from Tolson in the first half an hour, I thought that our performance was pretty mediocre. However, we deserved to win simply because Shrewsbury were so poor. I can't remember them making one attack of note before they scored; yet there was this awful inevitability that we would go to sleep and make life difficult for ourselves. It was Mansfield all over again. AL needs to make the players ruthless - when they'd gone 3-0 up, they should have put in some crunching tackles and kept going, rather than metaphorically set out the deck-chairs and invite them to attack us. Shrewsbury were abject, and it would have been a travesty if they had got anything out of the game.
  5. However, if we perform like that against Lincoln tomorrow, we'll get bugger all out of the game. Lincoln won 3-2 away (admittedly at Orient, who are having a horrible start to the season [so why could we only draw with them at the Hall ...?]) and are on a reasonably good run at the moment, so we need to be a lot sharper and a lot more ruthless. It appears that AL is aware of this (judging from some post-match comments), so lets hope he can instill this on the training pitch (whether John is there or not!).
  6. Best news of the day (Part I) - Carruthers signing. His performances with the Blues have definitely improved with time as he has begun to settle in the side, and I think he kind of has something to prove. I recall him being a bit of a danger man for Stoke when they were in Div. 1, and part of me feels that he will want to prove (to himself, mainly; but possibly also to the Darlo managaement) that he can play football of a similar standard again. A striker with something to prove is always a big asset - because the only way he can go about assuaging himself of the need of something to prove is by scoring goals, which is great news for us!
  7. Best news of the day (Part II) - Kath told me about the new fleeces they're selling in the club shop and having seen them myself I can confirm that they look absolutely fantastic. One of those is definitely on my Birthday list already (my Birthday comes before Xmas, so I'll get my hands on it sooner!).

I guess you want some ratings!

Mel - 6
(Tricky one, this. He did fantastically well with the attempted lob, but apart from that had little to do and still conceded 2. As I'm not a goal-keeping expert, I don't know whether his positioning could have been better for the goals - any views?)
Beard - 5
(Energetic, but didn't make much of an impression on the game)
Booty - 3
(Poor. Bad passing, bad positioning, no pace. If we revert to 4-4-2, he has to be dropped. Almost did a Patrick Vieira [v. Barcelona] by titting around with the ball in the box when he should have lumped it away... and Booty hasn't 10% of the skill of Vieira)
Coleman - 6
(Solid performance, although worrying signs that his lack of pace may prove increasingly problematic as the season wears on)
Roget - 7
(Another good performance, kept his temper largely under control - which was promising!)
Jones - 7
(Energetic performance again, showed good skill, although agree with another listee that AL definitely needs to instill the importance of tracking back to him)
Connolly - 5
(Same comments as Beard)
Tinkler - 5
(One of his poorer games; some wayward balls in the second half, and often prone not to chase the ball, allowing the Shrewsbury midfield to dictate the pace of the game. Needs to get stuck-in a bit more)
Houghton - 3
(One of his poorest games in a Blues shirt. Some horrendously wayward passing, aimless scrapping for the ball in front of the South Bank, and if Clarke had been on the bench, I certainly would have substituted Scotty)
Tolson - 7.5
(Deservedly MoM. In the first half an hour looked very sharp indeed - pacy, threatening, angular running style redolent of Allan Donald in full cry [if you've never seen Donald run up with the ball, he looks really scary with that war-paint on, I can assure you]. First half an hour, Tolson was on a 10 and looked set to bag four or five goals on his own; went pretty much off the boil after that, and if he hadn't been on his first league hat-trick for us, I'm sure that AL would have taken him off and brought on Neil Uncle Fester Campbell)
Carruthers - 7
(Good hunting partner for Tolson. Looked lively, well-taken goal, and kept going for longer than Tolson did. My runner-up for MoM, slightly ahead of Leo).

Good to meet a few more listees (Robin, Matt) as well as a couple of familiar faces (Kath, Phil, Bob), and hope to continue meeting a few of you in The Shrimpers... although it looks as if (mainly for family reasons) I won't be able to make it to the Hall until Hull, which is a shame. Anyhow, hope to see a few of you there.

Speak to you soon,

UP THE BLUES
Matt


Date: Sat, 16 Oct 1999 19:21:12 +0100
From: Colin Nicoll

Hi Folks,
almost a fortunate win today against another rather poor side.

Blues lined up :

Capleton
Booty Coleman Roget
Beard Connelly Tinkler Houghton Jones
Tolson Carruthers

no subs used.

The first half was so one sided with Blues strolling to an easy 3-0 lead after about 30 mins through good goals from Tolson (2) and Carruthers who had signed just before the game. Then it all started to go downhill and went in at 3-1 at halftime. Shrewsbury had been terrible for most of the half and apart from the goal their only real attempt was a long speculative lob which nearly caught Mel well off his line. Booty nearly helped them score dithering with the ball in front of his own goal which capped another poor performance by him.

The second half was also poor with Blues switching to 4-4-2 about halfway through with Beard moving into the centre of midfield but Shrews pulled one more back but luckily we held on until the end.

My MotM: Nathan Jones

The good points from this afternoon were: 3 points, Tolson looking a lot fitter, Carruthers signing, and both our strikers getting on the scoreboard.

We seemed to lack some real bite in midfield and personally I'd have preferred to see a 4-4-2 from the start with wingers instead of the tight formation we adopted today. Morley has played well in the reserves and deserves a run out soon.

Colin

The year's results


© Luke Bosman Monday, 23 April 2007 at 21:14:14

No part of this site may be reproduced without my prior permission.

Contributions and updates to the site are always welcome.