Blue Anorak

Last modified on Monday, 23 April 2007 at 21:14:07

Match report

Southend United 2-1 Plymouth Argyle

Date: Sat, 07 Aug 1999 19:04:26 +0100
From: Colin Nicoll
To: southend@isfa.com
Subject: Southend 2 Plymouth 1

Hi Folks,
With the new season here everyone was arriving at Roots Hall full of anticipation for what lies ahead. The whole atmosphere was so much better than the last 4 seasons.

John Main arrived in the West Stand Bar about an hour before kick off, did the rounds and as normal came across as a very nice bloke. A few things he did divulge were that Blues have a bid in for a player, but he wasn't letting on who. David Whyte will unlikely to be seen in a Blues shirt again, apparently his heart's not in it. John Main will be talking to the majority shareholder Monday about the possibility of selling the unsold shares from the recent rights issue.

I also heard in the bar that Arsenal are watching Mel.

Blues lined up in my favourite 4-4-2 formation:

Capleton
Booty Roget Coleman Jones
Connelly Beard Morley Houghton
Tolson Abiodun

Subs used:
Maher (70 mins) for Abiodun
Fitzpatrick (85 mins) for Tolson

Both teams were up for this match and with an unusually large crowd (I'd guess about 6000) for the opening game the including a large (late arriving due to an accident on the M25) following from Plymouth the scene was set.

I may have seen too many friendlies, but I thought that both teams played well above what I'd have considered 3rd div standard with Plymouth playing toward their supporters having more possession and looking slightly the better team. Both teams however created chances with Plymouth taking the lead through a local Southend lad Adam Barrett following a good spell of pressure. Tolson headed just over for Southend and Yemi blazed well wide when he had a reasonable chance. Roget did his normal thing and wound up the opposing supporters and played his part in getting a Plymouth player sent off I didn't see the incident but was told that it was a punch in the face. Roget was booked later, one of many I fear.

The second half, Plymouth with 10 men played more hit and run tactics and kept players behind the ball, but got forward with pace whenever they could. Blues tried every option they could and eventually brought on Maher for Yemi with Morley moving up front. This seemed to unsettle Plymouth and Blues scored soon afterwards with a great goal by Houghton who cut in from the left and shot right footed through a crowded penalty box. Blues piled forward with the crowd backed by the Band in the West baying from more. Tolson out jumped the keeper to score the second with Morley in close attendance. Fitzpatrick soon replaced Tolson and Blues held on until the end although Plymouth piled forwards and tested Mel a couple of times.

I enjoyed today's game and glad we got 3 points. I felt that it was a good all round performance with a much improved effort ratio over last season. Roget was awarded the offical MOtM, but for me it was David Morley who showed some great touches and passing for such a tall guy.

A special mention for the Band - this must be the best yet. Several times the whole of the crowded West Stand were joining in. The music carried the length of the stand and everyone I spoke to enjoyed a very good effort.

Colin


From: Matthew Weir
Subject: Re: Shrimpers 2-1 Plymouth
Date: Sun, 8 Aug 1999 18:55:54 +0100

A good start result wise but less so performance wise. We were totally over-ran in midfield, and the sending off seemed only to even things up rather than give us an advantage. This was particularly disappointing given Mark Beard's outstanding pre-season form. He and Morley just didn't gel as a combination. Please re-consider Mr Bushell!

Morley actually looked quite classy and seemed to impress everyone except the bloke behind me, who whinged on about how awful he is. I won't complain about him playing in midfield, I did after all suggest that this could be his best position. However, by playing him and Beard we're playing essentially two defenders in midfield whose instincts are defensive ie to sit deep rather than to attack, consequently leaving our attack isolated: we need one of these two to push forward at every opportunity.

I can't be alone in hating the way we defended our lead. Do we really need all 11 players in the penalty area to defend a corner against 10 men! What then tends to happen is because we have so many players in the area we will win the ball and clear it... straight back to the opposition again to put ourselves under more pressure. Push up!

At least some things were refreshing— the ref allowed someone within 5 yards of their keeper without blowing up and their manager didn't blame the ref but his own 'keeper for dropping it. The players didn't give up but battled, a few familiar faces are back watching the blues, and there was singing in the West Stand (although are these last few related? Well done once more the Band). The standard seems to have improved from last year with Plymouth looking as good as any team I can recall last year. And finally Kevin Maher made a positive contribution. I was about to start the Little Out chants when 1-0 down against 10 men, Little replaced a striker with a midfielder (Maher at that), in a move that stank of Alvin Martin, but it worked— all hail the messiah once more :-)

We are top of the league...
Matthew Weir


A Plymouth view:

I won't go into a match report, but basically what has been said already is about right— we looked pretty good, Southend looked poor, they didn't deserve 3 points.

But the Heathcote / Roget incident. I was sat (stood, at this point) 4 rows from the front, about 15 feet directly away from the confrontation. This is how I saw it (and yes, I know, everyone sees it differently, that's one of the things that makes football magic, so don't get stroppy if you disagree).

After the corner / cross had been dealt with, Mick and Roget squared up in the usual macho face-off. They both swore at each other, gave the evil eye. Roget gave Mick a shove in the chest— nothing big, didn't shift him. Mick reacted.

Right in the guy's face, hands on Roget's chest and gets real close. He the guy (a shove with his head, not a real Glaswegian kiss). He did make contact but it was just a touching of foreheads. I think Eskimos kiss like this. Anyway, for a split second, nothing happens, then Roget realises he could get Mick in trouble and goes down like the sack of proverbials.

Ref races over, by this time I know what's coming and he's off. Now I don't think the ref could have seen it. And he didn't go over and have the usual chat over tea and biscuits with his linesman. This is what annoyed most of the fans around me— basically, Roget has got Mick sent off. Now, the ref could have merely had a nod from his linesman, just to say yeah, the guy has to go, so the ref may have had enough information. Roget should have been carded/ sent-off for cheating. But this is not the point.

The point is this:

  1. Mick did not make significant contact. He did not hurt the guy but the intent was there. He made to headbutt the guy. Therefore whether or not Roget was hurt is irrelevant. (someone correct me if I'm wrong here)
  2. Mick is our best and most experienced player. He is our most important player. He always walks away from trouble. He knows (or should know) better. He didn't. He got himself sent off. Having only ten men did not help us in holding on to our lead. The man was an arse. Simple.

Ok, so later, our keeper drops the ball for their second goal (and he wasn't fouled, Veysey should have clattered the guy, keepers always get the benefit of the doubt).

As usual, we shot ourselves in the foot. So let's try not to be too paranoid about this. It is a trait among Argyle fans to think at least half of our defeats in a season are down to conspiracies and some sort of invisible hand of fate and that all referees are bent (which, of course, they are). Bliss and elation for about 30 mins, then sinking into the abyss of inevitability up to the final whistle. It's just like watching Argyle. I hate football. I love football.

The year's results


© Luke Bosman Monday, 23 April 2007 at 21:14:07

No part of this site may be reproduced without my prior permission.

Contributions and updates to the site are always welcome.