Blue Anorak

Last modified on Monday, 23 April 2007 at 21:13:56

Match report

Southend United 1-2 Hull City

From: Peter Cowell
Subject: The Hull disaster
Date: Sun, 14 Nov 1999 16:50:09 -0000

I'm still in shock recovering from Friday night. After looking foward all week to the home game with Hull, anticipating a win and climbing to 4th place— what happens?— we bloody well loose and instead of 4th we could end up 10th! How many more times will I fall for the same thing? Yet another false dawn.

First 15 mins I thought we just about edged it but for the next half hour until half time Hull were well on top and we were a little fortunate that they couldn't really get a shot on target despite creating chances and a certain amount of chaos around our goal.

2nd half we seemed to get things together and were at least equal to Hull. When Beard volleyed a superb shot (I thought his first touch was bad, but still managed to connect with the ball as it came down) I thought that would settle us down but then came the bizzare incident that lead to the first Hull goal.

I still don't know what really happened. (Does anyone?) I saw Mel stop the ball going out of play but didn't see what happened next (I was wandering about at the back of the West looking for Tony C's father-in-law who had gone missing and we feared had copped his lot in the Gents!). The next thing I knew there was a free kick given and they somehow, unbelievably, managed to get the ball in the net from the resulting free kick.

Peter Cline (a referee) writes:

The rules, basically interpreted, are that if a goal keeper controls the ball with his hands he cannot then touch the ball with his hands again. For example if a shot comes in and he makes a diving save with his hands then, to me, he has not got control so I would allow the keeper to pick the ball up, however if a shot comes in and he pats / pushes the ball down in front of him he has controlled the ball with his hands and cannot then pick the ball up. Hope this is clear.

To which Bob Sills adds:

I must admit I called out that's a free-kick before the nearest Hull forward raised his arm and appealed. By choosing to stop the ball going behind Mel did indeed control the ball with his hand.

Then about 8 mins later a reasonable shot from Hull that I think was going wide hit someone and the massive deflection left Mel stranded. End of game.

Bob Sills again:

I was also a bit baffled by his starting position for their second goal. Obviously he was left flat-footed by the massive deflection but from where I was he appeared to be standing practically on his right-hand post so I fear he would have struggled to get to it if the fella hit a decent shot towards the other corner. I thought all four midfielders on Friday were dreadful. Charlie, when we were leading I hasten to add, made the point that we do not appear to have the ability to unlock opponent's defences. If you are a team near the top, teams will put all their players behind the ball when they play you. We didn't even create the goal that we did score: it was a poor centre, which was scooped out to Beard via a very sloppy clearance.

What grated on me was the mis-placed passion our players showed. When Houghton was rightly hauled off he looked to the sky and screamed in frustration, similarly when the deflected shot went in several of our players held their heads, beat the turf etc... What a shame they didn't appear so fired up whenever the ball broke loose, we were so on our heels throughout the match it was unbelievable.

The mascots were the only highlight.

I felt we then finally lost the plot— a number of SUFC players were venting their frustration with niggly tackles, Beardo especially, rather than channelling everything onto the Hull goal. Mind you, I can't talk, I would have gone home and kicked the cat if I had one (we've only got goldfish and it wouldn't have been the same!).

I can't understand how we can play so well in the 2nd half against Brighton, then play not too well at all against Hull. Having said that, I thought Hull were at least as good as any team I've seen this season.

Although IMHO I thought the Hull number 23 (Steve Morgan) was giving Carruthers a real mauling off the ball and, while it seemed to achieve its objective, I thought the ref should have spotted it and sorted him out early on in the 1st half. Mind you, the prat of a linesman in front of the West (red / yellow flag) gave the ref no help at all. I'm sure he didn't know what offside was.

Kenny Goodbourn writes:

In the first 15 minutes alone that linesman missed Carruthers getting elbowed practically right in front him, gave a goal kick when it clearly came off the Hull defender's foot and waved up on a very bad offside decision.

I just can't stand going through the build up again as I did for the Hull game, only to yet again be brought down to earth and to take days to recover from it. That's the last time I let myself get so enthusiastic about it. In fact I've a good mind not to go to another game as long as I live...

When's the next game? Any places left on the coach to Chester? I'll never learn!

Gutted from Benfleet. (Peter C.)

The year's results


© Luke Bosman Monday, 23 April 2007 at 21:13:56

No part of this site may be reproduced without my prior permission.

Contributions and updates to the site are always welcome.