Match report
Exeter City 3-1 Southend United
Auto-Windscreens Shield, Second round
From: Colin Stratford
Subject: Another lacklustre display by Southend
Date: Wed, 06 Jan 1999 17:45:00
Source: mail.southend@isfa.com
I dragged myself along to St. James Park after work hoping to see an
improvement since watching the diabolical Torquay game. Yes we did play
better, but that wasn't hard to do! We created quite a lot of chance. Two
immediately after the first Exeter goal: the first a fierce shot by Burns
just inside the area which bought a tremendous save by the Exeter keeper; the
second was a powerful header by Conlon(?) from the resultant corner.
It was the usual long ball stuff using Conlon as the target man and Burns
feeding off him. Unfortunately, it just doesn't work. Neither Burns nor
Conlon are strikers!
Conlon got free late in the first half and was one on one with the keeper
only to blast over the top. We started off what looked to be a 4-4-2
formation only to change to 5-3-2 and finally ending up in the last 10
minutes as 4-3-3 with Newman making the extra man up front. The good
news was that we created chances but we haven't got a striker to finish them
off. Don't think that Maher played well just because he scored the goal, it
was a simple tap in that even Conlon couldn't miss.
The most disappointing thing for me was to see Coleman and Rob Newman effing and blinding at each other throughout the first half; there doesn't seem
much love lost there unless I'm mistaken. Coleman didn't seem to command any
respect from his teammates. It was another woeful performance but I feel
with a change of management that there is enough hidden talent in the team
to do well. Please Alvin resign now!
Ratings
- Margetson 6
- let down by bad defending
- Dublin 6
- played with some commitment
- Coleman 4
- worst game I have seen him play
- Newman 5
- not much better!!
- Beard 8
- played well throughout never gave up
- Gooding 5
- never really got involved
- Maher 5
- at least he scored but had an awful shot at the corner flag
- Livett 5
- poor game
- Jones 6
- replaced Livett did well
- Conlon 6
- several good headers nothing else though
- Burns 5
- crap
- Houghton 7
- started well but faded, appeared to be frustrated at our poor
defending and poor service.
As it was a nothing cup we should have blooded a few youngsters like Exeter, we may have got better commitment! At least Alvin could see how good they
were.
Colin Stratford.
From: Mike Wilding
Subject: Full-time Exeter 3-1 Shrimpers
Date: Tue, 05 Jan 1999 00:40:00
Source: mail.southend@isfa.com
Well, if the first half was bad, the second wasn't much better.
I wonder if we could persuade Alvin to go in goal and let Margerine out in
attack. He can certainly run faster than Conlon who often looks like a
raging tortoise and spends the rest of the time needing a zimmer frame to
stop himself falling over. If I sound unimpressed by his efforts tonight
then you judge right.
As the second half progressed, we looked no more likely to score than we did in the first half. Livett came off halfway through the second session to be replaced by Nathan Jones, who was then promptly ignored by all the team for
the first 10 minutes that he was on the pitch. With the team playing towards
us on their right flank, while Nathan stood in miles of open space on their
left.
In the whole of the second half, I can only remember us winning one header
when an Exeter player challenged for the ball. Our attack spent most of the
40 minutes giving the opposition a good gumming.
Newman managed to be both hero and villian within the space of two minutes. Having made a good challenge for the ball on the edge of the 5yd box and
headed the ball powerfully at the net, only to be parried by a fine reaction
save from the Exeter goalie, he then turned villian by kicking the resulting
corner over the crossbar from about 3 yds.
Then in the final five minutes, the game suddenly sprang into life, but only because a second goal for Exeter (Clark I think) reminded the squad that
they were about to loose the match. Then Nathan began to get chances down
the left flank and put in a cross for Maher to sidefoot into the far corner
of the net. And then, wonder of wonders, we began to look for a second!
Didn't last though, just on the edge of injury time a quick break by Exeter showed the team how to take the chances when they presented themselves and
we were back to being two behind. So then we started attacking with purpose.
Bit late and all in vain.
Still, it was nice to meet Tony Hall, who is getting married on Saturday. My congrats in advance. All mails directly to him. I've got a feeling that I
probably saw some others from the list, but just didn't know who they were.
Official crowd was 1143, of which we supplied 33 (including those who sat in the stand). The only satisfying thoughts of the evening? Their pitch has
one heck of a dip down one side, and the stadium made Roots Hall look
brilliant! Ahh, and finally, the chance to stand and watch a match. :o)
Regards
Mike.
|